The big problem with Canada’s transgender rights bill

(Linda Frum almost gets it!)

"Unclear as to why men who've had cosmetic surgery should be considered women for all intents and purposes. A man without a penis is still a man. We now have cases where rapist and murdering men who have had surgery are admitted to women's prisons and continue to rape with objects. There are multiple cases of men in Canada and the US harming women and children. "Unfortunately surgery may tend to change a man's look but it does not change his male pattern behaviour. No men should be admitted to spaces that have been designated woman only. Without going into lengthy detail, I can tell you that lesbians have been trying to keep men who think they are women out of their spaces for SEVENTY years and yet here again, the fed and prov govs are undermining lesbians'and all women's rights to assemble without including their oppressors. Women are now forced to meet in secret in order to have woman only events and organizations. "Also the reports of harms that trans ppl face have been greatly exaggerated in order to frame themselves as victims. In fact the opposite is true. We know in the US that trans id'd males are the demographic least likely to be killed. We know that in the UK trans id'd men are more likely to be murderers than murdered. We know in Canada there is no reported hate crime against trans - it's almost exclusively hate crime against ethnic minorities. We know that only two trans id'd men have been killed in all of Canadian history and that they were killed because they worked in the dangerous world of prostitution (not because they were trans), within which 1000's of Canadian women have also been murdered. We also know that the tales of suicide have been debunked. There is no epidemic of trans ppl killing themselves. "Please understand that there are many of us women and girls who don't want any men to occupy our words or spaces. As we've seen, it's now considered hate speech to state the dictionary definition that women are adult human females. If we lose the very word woman, then how are we to protect and enact our sex-based rights?" ** I couldn't publish my comment on this over two year old article (with not a single comment!) as my Facebook and Twitter are both banned. Hopefully FB will reinstate my account in a few days!

Comments

Popular Posts